⏭️ Plot Tests Skipped

No plot files changed

Compatibility:

Note: Only Python 3.13 is required to pass. Python 3.12 is tested for compatibility.

AI Review - Attempt 1/3

Quality Evaluation

Criteria Checklist

• VQ-001: Axes labeled correctly - X-axis "Temperature (°C)" and Y-axis "Month" are meaningful
• VQ-002: Visual clarity - Grid is subtle with alpha 0.2, clean plotly_white template
• VQ-003: Elements clear - KDE curves clearly visible with good fill and line styling
• VQ-004: No overlap - Labels don't overlap, distributions overlap intentionally as per spec
• VQ-005: Legend present - N/A (single data type with color gradient, no legend needed)
• VQ-006: Colorblind safe - Uses blue-to-red gradient, reasonable for sequential data
• VQ-007: Image size - Correct 4800 × 2700 px (1600×900 with scale=3)
• VQ-008: Title - "Monthly Temperature Distribution" is centered and clear
• CQ-001: Type hints - N/A for plot scripts (KISS style, no functions)
• CQ-002: Docstring - N/A for plot scripts (KISS style)
• CQ-003: Input validation - N/A for plot scripts (self-contained data)
• CQ-004: Clear error messages - N/A for plot scripts
• CQ-005: No magic numbers - Key values (spacing, scale_factor) are explained inline
• CR-001: Data accurate - Temperature data correctly mapped with seasonal patterns
• CR-002: Spec compliance - All spec requirements met:
  • ✓ Distributions overlap slightly (~15% as controlled by spacing)
  • ✓ Semi-transparent fills (opacity=0.75)
  • ✓ Gradient coloring from bottom (blue) to top (red)
  • ✓ KDE smoothing with scipy.stats.gaussian_kde
• CR-003: Edge cases - N/A (self-contained example data)

Issues Found

1. Minor: The overlap amount between distributions could be slightly more visible for stronger visual effect (currently ~15%, spec suggests 10-30% so this is acceptable)

Strengths

• Excellent use of plotly's capabilities with proper fill="toself" for closed shapes
• Good hover template with month name and temperature
• Proper two-pass approach: first calculate all KDEs, then add traces in reverse order for correct layering
• Clean color gradient from cool (Python Blue) to warm (Signal Red) colors
• HTML output uses CDN for plotly.js (best practice for file size)

AI Feedback for Next Attempt

Implementation is good. Minor improvement could be to increase the overlap slightly for more dramatic visual effect, but current implementation is within spec parameters.

Verdict: APPROVED